Press "Enter" to skip to content

MD Fla. Disagrees With, Distinguishes Beauvais in Fla. Foreclosure Statute of Limitations Case

Picture3The U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida recently confirmed that Florida’s statute of limitations did not bar a mortgagee from filing a new foreclosure action based on non-payment or other kinds of defaults within the past five years, even where the prior foreclosure action was dismissed without prejudice and acceleration of the mortgage occurred more than five years prior to the second foreclosure action.

In so ruling, the Court dismissed an amended complaint for declaratory judgment seeking to invalidate a mortgage.

A copy of the opinion is available at:  Link to Opinion.

A property owner sought a declaratory judgment that Florida’s statute of limitations bars a mortgagee from foreclosing on real property owned by the trust.  The subject property was originally purchased by two borrowers, who later failed to make their mortgage payments.

The mortgagee accelerated the mortgage loan, and filed a foreclosure action.  The borrowers filed for bankruptcy and received a discharge of their debts.  Thereafter, the first foreclosure action was dismissed without prejudice and the mortgage was assigned.

After one of the borrowers died, the remaining borrower quitclaimed her interest in the subject property to a trust’s personal representative.  The mortgagee then took possession of the property and prevented the trust’s personal representative from accessing and occupying it.

The trust’s personal representative filed suit against the mortgagee, relying on Deutsche Bank Trust Co., Americas v. Beauvais, No. 3D14-575, 40 Fla. L. Weekly D 1 (Fla. 3d DCA, Dec. 17, 2014), to argue that the Florida five-year statute of limitations period began to run as to the full amount owed on the mortgage on the date of the first acceleration, and that the mortgagee was therefore barred from foreclosing.

As you may recall, in Beauvais, Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal held that a second foreclosure action was barred by the statute of limitations when filed after a prior foreclosure action was dismissed without prejudice and more than five years after the date of acceleration.

The U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida declined to follow Beauvais, holding that the Beauvais decision was “contrary to the overwhelming weight of authority, which holds that ‘even where a mortgagee initiates a foreclosure action and invokes its right of acceleration, if the mortgagee’s foreclosure action is unsuccessful for whatever reason, the mortgagee still has the right to file later foreclosure actions . . . so long as they are based on separate defaults.’ ”

In addition, the Court distinguished Beauvais, which prevents re-filing of a foreclosure action as a result of non-payment defaults only, and not other kinds of defaults.  Here, the trust’s personal representative sought a declaratory judgment that the mortgage could not foreclose for any reason and also sought possession, occupation, and use of the subject property.

Accordingly, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida dismissed the amended complaint with prejudice.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Maurice Wutscher provides superlative defense and unmatched dedication to our clients in key cities nationwide. Chosen by Fortune 500 and midsize companies, financial institutions and other law firms for the successful resolution of their complex legal issues, we handle appellate matters, business formation and transactions, class action litigation, commercial, construction, consumer credit and employment litigation, contested bankruptcies and foreclosures, insurance recovery and advisory services, intellectual property litigation, privacy law, regulatory compliance, and trials and evidentiary hearings. Bold leadership, strategic guidance and sound insight are the hallmarks of the Maurice Wutscher professional. We are committed to providing unparalleled client service, efficiency, and thought leadership.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.